Trophyville, USA

Stomping Yankee fans in the City of Champions

Wednesday, March 22, 2006

Why trading Arroyo made sense (you EEI twits)

This guy echoes how i feel about the arroyo deal (though i wouldn't call it anything close to a "master stroke") .

Sox Beat: This could be a master stroke

By ALEX SPEIER
Union Leader Sports

THE REDS may revel after acquiring a twentysomething pitcher who will make a paltry sum in 2006, one year after he led the playoff-bound Red Sox in quality starts. Yet while Bronson Arroyo was perhaps the most consistent pitcher for a beleaguered Boston staff last year, his consistency was made up of mediocrity.

Arroyo (14-10, 4.51 ERA) often proved good but rarely exceptional. Though he led the team with 20 quality starts — six or more innings and three or fewer runs — he rarely exceeded the minimum requirements. His ERA translated almost exactly to three runs per six frames, slightly worse than the league average of 4.40.

‘Twas not always so. In 2004, Arroyo dominated at times while forging a 4.03 ERA, nearly a run better than that of an average AL colleague. He stroke out batters in bushels, most notably in a 12-strikeout performance against the Mariners that included a run of 11 straight outs by punchout.

That season, Arroyo’s sweeping curve proved unhittable at times. He fanned 7.15 batters per nine innings and permitted opposing hitters just a .249 average. The Sox, General Manager Theo Epstein noted, would not have won the World Series if not for his strong work.

After Arroyo started 2005 in similarly strong fashion (4-0, 3.21 in eight starts), opposing managers stacked their lineups with left-handers and right-handers started laying off the sweeping curve. Following those adjustments, Arroyo struggled to go 10-10 with a 4.97 ERA in his last 27 appearances; he fanned just 3.38 batters per nine frames in the second half of 2005.

None of that suggests a flop in Cincinnati. Indeed, removed from the meat grinder of the American League East (which battered Arroyo for a .290 batting average and 4.97 ERA last year), he could thrive anew.

“I think he’s going to have a very good year. He’s very tough on hitters who haven’t seen him before,” Epstein proclaimed. “Bronson has established himself at the big-league level. We didn’t have doubts about his ability. It was more about the fit with this year’s team.”

That team likely features six starters — Curt Schilling, Josh Beckett, Tim Wakefield, Matt Clement, David Wells and Jonathan Papelbon — who possess higher ceilings than a pitching-to-contact Arroyo. Lenny DiNardo (3.40 ERA in 42Ð innings for the Sox), meanwhile, possesses similar traits to his music-loving brethren.

Moreover, the organization features a number of starting (Jon Lester) and bullpen (Craig Hansen, Edgar Martinez) prospects who might have eventually leapfrogged Arroyo on the depth chart this year. That latter quality is one that was notably absent when the Sox plucked Arroyo from the waiver wire scrap heap in February 2003.

“We’re not counting on any one player from the minor leagues,” Epstein said. “But we feel that with the numbers that we have and the talent that we have, much as with Jon Papelbon last year, that when we get to July and August, somebody will be able to help us when we need it.”

While Arroyo once arrived to fill a need, his departure serves another. The team’s farm system was thin on mashers until larger-than-life Wily Mo Pena was acquired for Arroyo yesterday.

“It’s nice to have someone in the organization now,” noted Epstein, “who has a chance to really develop that kind of middle-of-the-order power.”

Whether Pena (career .248 average and .303 OBP) will fulfill that potential is anyone’s guess. He is perhaps the most free-swinging player in baseball, and has struck out more than once out of every three at-bats in his career. Yet when he makes contact, the ball disintegrates, evidenced by 51 homers in 830 at-bats. At the age of 24, there is time to grow.

“Pena is right about the age where he’ll either improve his plate discipline enough to be productive,” noted one baseball executive, “or we can write off any shot of him being a useful regular.”

The Sox offer the example of Jesse Barfield to suggest that a player can make the leap. The former Jays star hit .247 with a .303 OBP in three years before turning 24, then amassed a .288 average, .366 OBP and .530 slugging average (third best in baseball) over the next three years.

That promise made yesterday’s risk/reward proposition palatable to the Sox. So, too, did the likelihood that the team gave up a pitcher who once performed an indispensable function but now seemed redundant.

Alex Speier covers the Red Sox for the New Hampshire Union Leader and Sunday News.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home